Welcome to Pick A Bagel New York
At Pick A Bagel New York, we believe in crafting the ultimate bagel experience rooted in tradition and quality. Located at 1101 Lexington Ave, our establishment serves an array of New York's famous bagels, from classic Everything to hearty Pumpernickel, each priced at just $2.99. Our commitment to freshness extends to our breakfast sandwiches, featuring delightful combinations like Bacon, Egg, and Cheese, all made to order. Customers rave about our extensive cream cheese selections and speedy, friendly service, making us a cherished spot for a quick bite or leisurely brunch. Join us and savor the essence of New York, one bagel at a time!
-
1101 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10075 Hotline: (212) 517-6590
Welcome to Pick A Bagel New York, a true gem nestled in the heart of the city at 1101 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10075. If you’re a bagel aficionado or just someone craving a hearty breakfast, this place is a must-visit. Renowned for its authentic New York-style bagels, this establishment proudly serves an array of options that will satisfy any palate.
Here, you’ll find everything from the time-honored Everything Bagel to the wholesome Whole Wheat Bagel, each available for just $2.99. The selection doesn’t end there; indulge in the Garlic, Poppyseed, Onion, Pumpernickel, Plain, and Sesame varieties, all freshly baked and ready to delight your taste buds.
But that’s not all! For those seeking a more substantial meal, the Bagel Breakfast Sandwiches make for a delightful start to your day. Choose from a variety of sumptuous combinations like the classic Bacon, Egg, & Cheese or the fulfilling Pastrami, Egg, & Cheese, each priced around $10.99. Don’t overlook the coveted NY Smoked Salmon Bagel, a luxurious treat that combines fresh scotia salmon with onions, cream cheese, and your choice of bagel for $22.99.
Customer reviews echo a common theme: the bagels are not only fresh but also remarkably chewy and satisfying. “Great choice of bagels but also so many types of cream cheese offerings!” raved one happy diner. Another commented, “If you’re looking for the classic NY bagel, this is great!” The friendly atmosphere adds to its charm, with quick service that makes even the busiest mornings feel manageable.
- Location: 1101 Lexington Ave, New York, NY
- Phone: (212) 517-6590
- Price Range: Bagels - $2.99, Breakfast Sandwiches - $7.99 to $22.99
While some patrons note that the place can get busy with a small wait, most agree it’s worth it. After all, where else can you find such a delightful assortment of both bagels and cream cheese that evoke the spirit of New York? Whether you’re a local or a visitor, make sure your bagel journey includes a stop at Pick A Bagel New York. It’s a taste of tradition in a city that never sleeps.
Great choice of bagels but also, so many types of cream cheese offerings! Fresh and cash bagels or sandwiches.
If you're looking for the classic NY bagel this is great! Recommended to us by our concierge and we enjoyed it. The service here was extremely friendly and quick. There were plenty of places to sit on a Friday morning. Portions were reasonable for the price. Enjoy!
Good combo for this price. Better than take on a food truck Fresh baked Slow service No restroom
Bagel was good, fresh, and chewy. Everything you'd want in a decent B.E.C sandwich. Could've used more cheese and salt but it's hard to get a simple sandwich like this to be made good. Good, hot, fast service.
Pricey but if you are craving some bagels, I recommend. I was starving and while I waited by Lenox hospital I passed by and decided to get one. Everything bagel with everything cream cheese and the butter toasted bagel Definitely recommend but it is on the pricey side hit what isn't these days.
I'd give an ok. A little above average. Arrived at 8:30 on a Sunday morning. Small line that moved quickly. Got my everything with cream cheese and coffee. Coffee lukewarm. Bagel fresh and good. Not delicious. Well seasoned with a nice chewability. Place is clean with stools along a window counter to sit at. Staff a little noisy, talking over the music to each other, but still giving decent service. If I worked at Lenox Hill Hospital across the street or lived within a 3 block radius this would be my bagel place. Otherwise I'd be going somewhere else. See my video review on IG @bagelmavennyc
So far only tried their regular coffee & blueberry muffin . And after first time I stopped going to Starbucks & dunking donuts for coffee . And the blueberry muffin I had been getting, one of the best I had. Infect I m so much in love with it that scared to try a different flavor the muffin is huge too, I can't finish the whole thing at once so at lunch time when I get hungry I finished the rest. They are always packed, but service is very fast . So far didn't have any incidents to make my day worse ! Thank you soo much for your service & Ofcource yummy food !