Pick A Bagel New York Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Pick A Bagel New York, a delightful gem located at 1101 Lexington Ave that serves authentic New York-style bagels. This eatery is known for its extensive bagel menu, featuring classic options like Whole Wheat, Garlic, and Everything bagels, all priced at just $2.99. Their bagel breakfast sandwiches are a must-try, showcasing a creative variety such as the Turkey Bacon, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich, and the Pastrami, Egg, & Cheese, each available for $10.99.
One highlight is the NY Smoked Salmon Bagel, a lavish treat at $22.99, crafted with fresh scotia salmon and your choice of bagel and cream cheese. Customers rave about the fast and friendly service, effortlessly pairing freshly baked bagels with delicious cream cheeses. Despite a few comments on pricing and service speed, the overall experience promises warmth and authenticity typical of a New York bagel shop. Stop by and indulge!
New York Famous Bagels
Plain Bagel
New York famous plain bagel
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
New York famous whole wheat everything bagel.
Whole Wheat Bagel
New York famous whole wheat bagel.
7 Grain Bagel
New York famous 7-grain bagel.
Sesame Bagel
New York famous sesame bagel.
Poppyseed Bagel
New York famous poppyseed bagel.
Everything Bagel
New York famous everything bagel.
Pumpernickel Bagel
New York famous pumpernickel bagel.
Garlic Bagel
New York famous garlic bagel.
Onion Bagel
New York famous onion bagel.
NY Smoked Salmon Bagel
Fresh scotia salmon with onions and customer's choice of bagel and cream cheese.
New York Famous Lox Bagels
The Bagel Breakfast Sandwiches
The Egg Sandwich
Exquisitely made scrambled eggs sandwich wrapped in customer's choice of bread.
The Egg & Cheese Sandwich
Scrambled eggs tossed with customer's choice of cheese and their choice of bread.
Bacon, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich
Scrambled eggs tossed with customer's choice of cheese, crispy bacon strips, and customer's choice of bread.
Turkey Bacon, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich
Scrambled eggs tossed with customer's choice of cheese, crispy turkey bacon strips, and customer's choice of bread.
Turkey, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich
Scrambled eggs tossed with customer's choice of cheese, fresh turkey slices, and customer's choice of bread.
Ham, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich
Scrambled eggs tossed with customer's choice of cheese, fresh ham slices, and customer's choice of bread.
Sausage, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich
Scrambled eggs tossed with customer's choice of cheese, fresh sausage slices, and customer's choice of bread.
Pastrami, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich
Scrambled eggs tossed with customer's choice of cheese, fresh pastrami slices, and customer's choice of bread.
Side of Bacon
Crispy slices of bacon.
Potato Salad
Chef's fresh potato salad.
French Toasts
Customer's choice of French toast.
Pancakes
Customer's choice of pancakes.